11/01/2026
“Should I size up?” The question we get most.
Peloton shoes run true to size, but a stiff sole and narrow shape make them feel snug.
Between sizes? Size up. A slightly long shoe can be snugged up with straps; a short one can’t be fixed.
And if you still pick the wrong size, our 100% Fit Guarantee covers a free exchange!
Read the full sizing guide at https://tommasocycling.com/blogs/tommaso-nation/do-peloton-shoes-run-small
Peloton shoes feel snug by design. Learn how they should fit, when to size up, the signs a pair is too small or too big, and fixes to try first.