05/01/2020
AN OPEN LETTER TO YourAlberta (Government of Alberta)
RE: The future of the health and fitness industry in our province
Dear Premier Jason Kenney,
Like most Albertans, we have been anxiously waiting for updates as to the lifting of restrictions on Alberta businesses due to COVID-19. As a small Edmonton-based studio specialising in personal training and small group fitness, we were part of the first cohort mandated to close our doors back in March. Since then, we have been working virtually non-stop to find ways to sustain our operations until our doors can re-open, in a safe and sustainable manner.
For us, the past 7 weeks have been a careful balance of actively wanting to prioritize the immediate health and safety of our clients and fellow Albertans in regards to this pandemic, while simultaneously recognizing the critical role that studios such as ours play in the larger scheme of public health and social wellness.
Like many locally-owned and operated studios, ours caters primarily to populations that are unable to access mainstream fitness options for a variety of reasons. We also house Diversifit, a non-profit dedicated to supporting families of children with disabilities with their physical fitness needs and gross motor literacy. It provides free of charge workshops, education programs and fitness events to promote general health and wellness, and has been a vibrant part of Edmonton’s fitness community since it opened its doors. It is much more than a ‘gym’ to our members. Most small fitness studios are.
Throughout this crisis, the government has categorized all gyms, regardless of their size, as public recreation and/or leisure facilities, categorizing us alongside bars, nightclubs, recreational facilities, arenas and swimming pools. Under the current plan to lift restrictions, this would place all fitness facilities in the very last phase of re-opening, denying the public access to meaningful, in-person support for their physical health.
While this categorisation might well reflect the reality of some of the larger fitness facilities, particularly franchised or nation-wide centres, it simply fails to address the breadth and scope of the fitness industry as a whole, and ignores the differences between these large-scale operations and smaller ones that cater to more specialized populations and programs. Additionally, this classification belittles and disregards the very real role that exercise professionals play in public health. Exercise is absolutely recreation and leisure, but it is also a critical aspect of health care.
Exercise specialists, including Physiologists, Athletic Therapists, Corrective Exercise Specialists, Certified Personal Trainers, and Certified Fitness Instructors, provide ongoing exercise management of chronic illness, injury prevention/rehabilitation, and physical and mental health. Research has repeatedly shown us that ‘exercise is medicine’, and that the best way to ensure long-term protection against future flare-ups of COVID-19 and similar pandemics is to ensure an active and healthy population. Beyond this, a well-structured and supported fitness program is a powerful tool for combating stress, anxiety and mental illness, something which should be at the forefront of our considerations when exploring the long-term effects of the pandemic.
What this categorization fails to recognize is that those most likely to be negatively affected by COVID-19 are exactly those most likely to seek out exercise specialists to support them: seniors, those living with diabetes/asthma/cardiac and respiratory conditions, and/or other chronic health conditions placing them in the high risk categories. Many of these populations require very specific exercise prescriptions, as well as the support and supervision of professionals, to be successful in improving their health outcomes.
While online support is possible, and most facilities have worked hard to offer our services virtually, there are simply some aspects of our work that can not be done effectively over zoom calls or virtual classes. Movement and fitness assessments, especially with medically fragile or physically compromised people, really should be done under close supervision of professionals in order to prevent injury and minimize risks.
It is difficult to comprehend how services that cater to individual aesthetics and grooming are seen as a higher priority than those that literally provide life-saving and quality of life altering supports. We can only conclude that there is a misguided belief that most people are able to care for their physical needs independently. However, any thorough examination of public health literature will indicate that the vast majority of the population struggles with self-efficacy when it comes to their physical activity needs, and are already under-active by health standards. We have absolutely no reason to believe that this struggle will be lessened by COVID-19, and every reason to believe that it will be exacerbated.
It is our sincere hope that the government will reconsider its all-encompassing definition of ‘gyms’ to recognize that different fitness services require different levels of social contact and exposure. The same arguments that can be made for reopening massage therapy and reflexology should no doubt apply to one-on-one exercise training, and arguably even small group training.
What we are asking is that the government add the following to Phase 2 of its Relaunch Strategy, along with other similar industry models such as massage, reflexology and physiotherapy.
1) That Physiologists, Athletic Therapists, Certified Personal Trainers, Certified Corrective Exercise Specialists and Certified Group Fitness providers may resume services as long as they are provided in accordance with all health regulations and adhere to all physical distancing standards.
2) That exercise and physical fitness facilities offering one-to-one training and small group training of less than 10 participants may reopen provided that they adhere to the physical and social distancing regulations and measures in place, and do not exceed a total capacity of 15 people within the facility at any given time.
Should the government fail to recognize the nuances within our field, and the distinct differences between large centres and smaller ones, I believe that I can safely say that the majority small studios and fitness professionals will be completely wiped out by the time we are able to open. We are simply not able to provide the quality and types of services that make us distinct and vital contributing members of Alberta’s economy online or ‘curbside’. And while this would be a great loss for Alberta’s economic and business scene, it would be an even greater loss to our public health system and to those who rely on our professional services in order to maintain functional fitness and a baseline quality of life.
Sincerely,
Zita Dube-Lockhart (BA, DIP HS) CSEP CPT/ NASM CES/ AFAA GFI
Owner, Generate Fitness
Toni Harris (DIP HS) CSEP CPT/NASM CES
Owner, In Your Boots Fitness