06/03/2026
[RIGHT V WRONG QUESTION]
When Coach asked the players after the very disappointing loss âwhere do you think you and we are at?â - that was the wrong question to ask after a preseason game obviously. After all, itâll take us at least 3 regular season games to know where weâre at - unless weâre Carlton.
But coach didnât ask that question after last Friday nightâs drubbing. Instead, he asked the lads that question last July immediately after losing by almost 9 goals to the Pies in round 12. And as much as thatâs the wrong question to ask last Friday, it was the right question back in the middle of the season after getting flogged - our hunt and work rate were off a bazillion miles, with 12 blokes not laying one single tackle.
But when comparing the other stats from round 12 last year to last Fridayâs preseason hit out - not including tackles and the actual scoreboard - the stats were, first, surprisingly favourable to us, and second, eerily similar, because in both games we either won or broke even in all of clearances, contested possies, hit outs, and inside 50s.
So sure, the stats looked decent enough, but still, whether you watched either game on TV or at the ground, both looked horrendous to the Mighty Fighting faithful ⊠both sh!tshows for big chunks. Because when the pill spilled from the contest, we got thrashed on the outside - chasing tale, never seeing the pill again, and conceding snags.
Which leads this column to the question that Coach will have pondered not just last Friday night, but ever since our prelim loss last September:
âAre we setting the ground up right?â
Because the truth is, Coach is tweaking how he sets up the ground compared to previous seasons - because too often last season especially we couldnât get the pill out of D50 against the top 6 sides, with Coach now doubling down on a front half game.
In other words, numbers behind the pill, with our elite half backs (Sis, Scrim, Karl and Dimma) pushing really high up the ground - with a willingness to pull the trigger and launch the pill by foot to Lewis and co at half forward, rather having to always switch to the fat side and run, run, run all the time, which sure, worked pretty well against weaker oppo, but was a trick that Shelbyville took away from us in the prelim all too easily, making it very hard to move the pill.
And yes, setting up the ground different didnât work too well against the Bullies obviously. But that wasnât the ground being set-up wrong by Coach most likely. Rather, we got out worked and made too many blunders and poor decisions. Ex*****on and work rate were the problem, not game plan and strategy. Which is a preseason game problem, not an opening round one fingers crossed.