Fishthief Custom Lures

10/18/2025

10/16/2025

Check out all the custom glow lures still available for the end of this fishing season! The browns and salmon are still hot! Very flexible on pricing, my goal is to get you catching fish! Reach out and we can work out a price…. Stay safe and tight lines! 

10/16/2025

Check out our new Glow Series. Specifically designed to target perch and other panfish this ice fishing season. If you’re looking for something specific, shoot me a message and I’m happy to design whatever you need. 

03/31/2025

Just in time for Spring Brown Trout Fishing! Fishthief Custom Lures has you covered with spoons and lures specially designed to catch more trout. Please check back soon as we will have Mother’s Day and Father’s Day Packages .Next week we will be launching our stick bait series! Guaranteed to catch fish on your next trip!

02/16/2025

Tired of your brother-in-law stealing your favorite lures? Fishthief Custom Lures has you covered. Our proven colors and patterns will ensure your next fishing trip is a successful one. Not only will the fish stay in your boat, so will your lures with these personalized spoons
from Fishthief Custom Lures.

02/14/2025

Spring trout fishing on the South Shores of Lake Ontario is right around the corner! If this season is anything like last year, be ready to fill your coolers. Check out all the new spoons from Fishthief Custom Lures that are proven to put more fish in your boat. Please make sure to check back next week as we’ll be putting up our first of several tutorial videos. 

Shop Custom painted spoons and personalized fishing gifts! by FishthiefCustomLures located in Rochester, New York.

02/09/2025

Personalize your fishing experience with these beautiful customized engraved tin boxes. Pick any 4 lures plus your customized box for just $50! All you need to do is send us your lure selection and what you want personalized. Perfect gift idea for the fisherman in your life!

02/09/2025

All individual spoons -$8

02/09/2025

Fishthief Custom Lures are all handmade products to order. Our wide selection of colors, sizes and hooks allow you to create the perfect lure or spoon for your next fishing experience. Don’t see something you need. Send us a picture or tell us what you’re looking for and we will make it for you. Perfect gift idea! We customize spoon boxes with the name of your boat engraved.