Nicodemus Cards & Gaming

Nicodemus Cards & Gaming The OFFICIAL home of Nicodemus Cards & Gaming! Support your LCS! Pokémon
Disney Lorcana
Magic: The Gathering
Topps
Upper Deck
ONE PIECE CARD GAME
Yu-Gi-Oh!
(1)

Nicodemus Cards & Gaming is a premier trading card store located in Warsaw, IN, serving surrounding areas since 2020. Specializing in trading cards, gaming supplies, and card grading, we are your one-stop shop for all things related to card collecting and gaming. Our store offers a vibrant atmosphere for card enthusiasts to participate in tournaments, engage in open-play sessions, and connect with

fellow collectors. Whether you're a seasoned pro or just getting started, Nicodemus Cards & Gaming is the ultimate destination for all your trading card needs. Services:
Card Grading
Grading
Tournaments
Board Games
Card Valuation

Specialties:
PSA Grading
Open Play
Card Tournaments

Products:
Cards
Sports Cards
Board Games
Card Supplies
Game Supplies
Card Decks
Card Boxes
Trading Card Singles

Brands:
Play! Star Wars: Unlimited
Warhammer
Panini America
Marvel
DC Comics

06/18/2026

Aaaaand that's a wrap on this box! Was it any good?

06/16/2026

We are back for another Weekend Outlook! Lots of great stuff this weekend! Magic, One Piece, Pokemon and lots of Open Play!

06/16/2026

Trust me on this one.

nicodemus cards and gaming local game store for you page trending trust fall funny warsaw indiana funko pops magic the gathering tog lorcana yugioh one piece new set

06/15/2026

Great turnout! Thanks to everyone who came!

magic tournament Igbtq wlw token artifact elves hobby shop nicodemus cards and gaming store local downtown warsaw indian trading card game local game store Igs fyp foryou

06/15/2026

Second to last rip of this Booster Box!

06/15/2026

We're doing buybacks! Bring in any of these and trade them for store credit. Base cards are $20 of store credit, refractors are $40 credit, numbered cards of 100 or higher are $100 credit, and 99 or lower is $200 credit.
Check the Topps website for more information!
shai gilgeous-alexander baseball cards wwe cards basketball cards local game store Igs fyp card store warsaw indiana

06/14/2026

It's not their fault we have a great selection.
Check out our TCG binder at Nicodemus Cards and Gaming! foryou magic the gathering trending game store card games sports cards Igs local game store

06/11/2026

Grace is rippin' One Piece today! We want to see you tomorrow when the sleeves and starter decks drop! And of course, PACKS!!!

06/11/2026

Here we go again! Episode 6 or rippin Wild's Unknown!

Series 2 Baseball drops today! Hobby, Jumbo, Blaster/Value, & Hanger Boxes! All in stock!
06/10/2026

Series 2 Baseball drops today! Hobby, Jumbo, Blaster/Value, & Hanger Boxes! All in stock!

WOW: An ultra-rare Munetaka Murakami 'Home Field' Rookie Card has surfaced on eBay 🤯

A Chicago native needs this.

Address

118 W Market Street
Warsaw, IN
46580

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 2pm
Tuesday 12pm - 6pm
Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 7pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm
Sunday 12pm - 5pm

Telephone

+15745499945

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Nicodemus Cards & Gaming posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category