29/08/2022
IMITATING ANIMALS?
By Phillip Starr
There are some martial arts, mostly Chinese, that seek to imitate the movements of certain animals. This is, I believe, a flawed approach to the effectiveness of many of their techniques. We're not tigers, reptiles, or insects; we're human and I believe that we should learn and practice the most effective ways for humans to move rather than vainly attempting to move in the manner of other creatures.
Tigers, for instance, can strike from the outside inwards with incredible power. This is largely because they don't have clavicles that articulate with the other bones as is found in humans. Our clavicles prevent us from striking as powerfully a tigers. On the other hand, tigers cannot strike from the inside out with any substantial measure of power for the same reason, nor can they lift heavy objects with their forelegs and paws. We can.
Snakes strike by literally hurling themselves at their prey. If they miss, they fall flat! And praying mantises do the same thing (although they do so with incredible speed). But if the prey moves, the end result is the same; the mantis falls flat. And when a mantis seizes its prey, it has sharp barbs on the undersides of its forelegs that dig into the victim to help prevent its escape. We have no such structures on the undersides of our forearms.
Apes have enormously powerful arms and chests, enabling them to strike with incredible force. Their arms are quite long as well, and this allows them to swing easily on branches and other things with apparent ease. Our arms are much shorter and weaker.
It is more effective and, I think, more interesting to examine their tactics more closely. This is what styles such as xingyiquan do. Aside from its linking form and a couple of others that basically re-hash the basic linking set, they have short sets (or, in many cases, just one longer form) that are based on the fighting/hunting tactics used by twelve different creatures. Tigers always hit their prey from its blind side and they kill with a single, powerful blow to the neck. Lions are different; they prefer to bite into the victim's throat and strangle it.
Cranes will flap their wings to beat an aggressor while they use their long, hard beaks to jab (often at the eyes). Eagles swoop down on their prey, usually breaking its spine when they strike with their claws.
Again, I think we need to focus on moving in the most efficient way for HUMANS to move and learn the most efficient ways of striking with as much power as HUMANLY possible.