11/01/2023
Running vs. Walking: The Debate Continues
Running and walking are the two most popularly used form of exercise in the U.S. There has always been an ongoing debate on which is better for you in the long run. It's already been proven that both are great for your health.
Any exercise is better than sitting on your rear all day. So which will you choose to do? Both will help squash high cholesterol, diabetes, heart disease, and high blood pressure, but when it comes to comparing them side by side and determining which is best for you, the debate depends on your personal needs.
Running
Running's biggest winning factor is its calorie burning and metabolism pumping effects. If you are looking to lose, weight and get fit, running beats walking with a sledgehammer. Not only does running burn way more calories per hour than walking, which makes a big difference in weight management, but studies have shown that running helps to suppress appetite. This appetite suppression comes from the release of a hormone called peptide YY.
This means that those who run will be eating less than those who walk. They will be burning more calories during and after exercise. Less calories in and more calories out translates into a thinner waistline for all runners.
Running can be overdone, however. A study of the heart of marathon runners showed that excessive long distance running caused scar tissue to accumulate on the heart. This scar tissue could possibly lead to myocardial fibrosis, arrhythmias and atrial fibrillation, premature aging of the heart, and cause the muscles of the heart to stiffen. These facts show that too much of a good thing can be bad.
It should be reiterated that this only showed in runners who ran excessively. Micah True, was known for running some 50-100 miles at a time, died with a scarred and enlarged heart, and his death was ruled as most likely due to arrhythmia or an irregular heartbeat.
So, don't be afraid to run. Just make sure you are being moderate in your running. The suggested amount is to run 30-45 minutes, 3-4 days a week at a pace of a mile every 10 minutes.
Walking
Some might consider walking as a way to get from point A to point B, not so much of an exercise. However, walking has many benefits, no doubt about it. You can burn just as many calories walking as you do running; you just have to keep at it longer. Many consider walking a better choice than running because it is easier on the joints.
While running, if you don't have the necessary muscle strength to support your joints, don't run in the correct alignment, or don't wear shoes with the proper support you could be damaging precious tissue around the knees, hips, and ankles. With a regular walking exercise program, you are treating your joints more carefully.
There are studies that show that walking may have a stronger health benefit than running. The study shows that running an hour a day will reduce your risk of heart disease by 4.5% while walking reduced that same risk by 9%.
Of course, most walkers are at the beginning of their exercise journey and so had more risk of heart disease to begin with since they recently came out of their sedentary lifestyle. In addition, it is much harder to walk enough to burn the same amount of energy as most runners do, as it would take much more time to burn that same amount of energy walking.
Brisk walking and not easy strolling is your best choice when looking to lose weight and support heart health.
The debate ranges on. There are many who enjoy running. Some think walking is a more stress relieving way to exercise. Both will get you healthier than you were before by helping you manage your weight, blood pressure, and benefit your heart. Both also build muscle strength in the lower body, and even in the arms if you move your arms while walking.
If you can run, run (but not too much!).
If you'd rather walk, walk. (make sure it’s brisk and quick, and frequent!)
The point is to move, no matter how you do it, and to move regularly.