06/27/2026
The Blues have acquired Brandon Carlo from the Maple Leafs for the 73rd and 76th overall picks in the 2026 Draft.
Carlo is a 29-year-old, 6-foot-5, right-handed defenseman who’ll add some extra veteran presence to an overall young blue line. He’s a steady, defense-first player who averaged 19:22 of ice time last season in Toronto. You can’t expect much offense or excitement from him, with 0 goals and 10 assists over his last two seasons (73 games). The Leafs gave up a 1st-round pick and a top prospect to acquire him in 2024-25, so paying two third-round picks doesn’t seem too shabby.
Right now, the blue line looks something like this (pairings will change):
Broberg - Parayko
Lindstein - Carlo
Fowler - Mailloux
Ex: Tucker
With this trade, it appears the Blues don’t expect Adam Jiricek to make the roster out of camp, which makes sense considering he’s coming straight from juniors. Carlo is a nice transition piece who’ll help the Blues in their goal to “compete” and fight for a Wild Card spot. He’s also a great player to dangle at next year’s trade deadline if Jiricek is ready and/or the Blues aren’t in the playoff picture. He has one year remaining on his contract at a $4.1M AAV.
Overall, it’s a solid trade for what the Blues are trying to accomplish. They want to make the playoffs, and Carlo helps them do that without getting too much in the way of the organization’s long-term development.