06/14/2026
In case you really really want to try an 1855 pistol carbine.
Experimental archaeology is a historic approach that “tests historical hypotheses by recreating past technologies and everyday practices.”
In other words, experimental archaeology is learning history by trying to perfectly replicate how they did things in the past.
This is why I endlessly bothered John Morgan until he made me some correct 450-grain pistoI-carbine bullets, to test in the M1855 PistoI-Carbine. Everything was replicated as close as possible to the historic original: the pistoI is original in excellent condition, John’s bullets are precise recreations of the historic ones, the powder load and cartridge were also painstakingly replicated, and even the Maynard primer tape was carefully made using real mercury fulminate, exactly like they were in 1855. Like the famous historian Von Ranke said, this lets us step back in time and experience history „wie es eigentlich gewesen,” or as it actually was.
Experimental archaeology turns a fun range day into a serious historical research project at the same time!
This educational historic research reached a conclusion: the M1855 PistoI-Carbine sucks. Sorry, Jeff Davis.
But really though, this thing was a bad idea. Very cool, and historically significant, but it was obsolete before day one and was a lousy pistoI and even worse as a carbine. Fun to shoot though!