09/03/2026
Q&A: What do you actually write down during tryout evaluations? Specific, observable actions tied to a consistent scale, not general impressions, since general impressions are exactly where bias and favoritism quietly creep into a process that needs to be fair.
Use the same simple rubric for every player across every session, scoring specific things you can actually see, defensive stance, communication, effort on loose balls, decision making under pressure, rather than relying purely on memory at the end of a long tryout period. Have more than one evaluator scoring independently whenever possible, then compare notes afterward, since a second set of eyes catches things a single evaluator, however experienced, is going to miss.
Keep these written evaluations on file, not just in your head, so you have something concrete to point to if a parent or player asks how a decision was made. A documented, consistent process protects you and, more importantly, actually gives every kid trying out a fair, honest shot.
Follow Underdog Hoops for more basketball coaching content.