06/09/2024
There is a fair amount of talk on social threads and other media on the lack of depth in the women’s game. I don’t know if this matters to the dominance of ALW as her absolute skill may stand the test of time in any future era.
That said I think pickleball may have a bro problem. When I started playing pre pandemic the game was pretty equal on gender at the 3.5-4.0 level at any given park. It was mostly older players with a few younger players getting into the game.
Now of my groups which skew younger on team reach, group me, text threads, what’s app, etc at the 4.5+ level . . . they are all dominated by dudes. It’s not even close as 90% of the names are guys.
My theory on why this exists is the misguided belief that the ONLY way to get better is to play with better players. These groups are formed with a very protective nature over the “quality” of their games.
As there is some truth to the aspect that you need to see better balls to get better, it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.
A theory of mine is that as banging is a phase of the game around the 3.5-4.0 level these groups begin to form based on power alone initially which leaves many ladies out of the mix. That said this game at its core is one of the more gender neutral in sports as it rewards placement, strategy, and coordination over raw power. Just watch ALW in any given dreambraker and it’s clear women have what it takes to hold their own. This isn’t the case in basketball or other highly physical sports where the gap in ability is much wider.
However, I really don’t know for sure why women are less represented in advanced groups around the country. Is it a social trend, like bros doing bro things, or is there a more technical explanation as I describe above?
For instance look at the videos Zane and Jack Munro are putting out . . . it’s a bunch of pro bros beating up on their 5.0 bros. The only one that I can recall that has pro ladies are showing them getting pushed off the court in a comic exaggeration of the pro mixed game.
I don’t think Zane is driving this bro trend (and his videos are quite good so I am not discrediting them) rather he is just a product of what the market is becoming. It’s migrating to a game of bros for bros and he as a smart b-school kid is tapping into that.
That said there is no doubt that men are dominating the advanced local groups right now. And just like any other sport, it’s all about the funnel. If there are fewer ladies in the advanced funnel objectively, based on what I am seeing across many towns across the country, you will see fewer at 5.5 and beyond. And the next ALW may be years not months away.
But does it even matter for the sport? Let me know your thoughts.