07/08/2022
This!
Although it can be easy to think that strength training can provide a form of cardio if you're looking at heart rate (HR) alone, it's important to understand that's not how it works
To understand why, we have to look at the differences between what's happening under the hood when we do both types of training
First, it's important to recognize the whole point of doing "cardio" is to build our cardiovascular system. This system is central to aerobic metabolism and fitness because its job is to pump oxygen throughout the body
When we do traditional cardiovascular exercises like running, cycling, rowing, etc., our heart rates go up as intensity increases because we're asking our cardiovascular system to deliver more oxgen to all the working muscles and supporting tissues
In this case, we see a very linear relationship with how much oxygen is being pumped throughout the body and our HR
In other words, a higher HR means our cardiovascular system is working to deliver more oxygen
This challenge to the cardiovascular system is the stress that causes it to adapt and become better at pumping more blood and oxygen, i.e. why our aerobic fitness improves
When we're lifting heavy weights, on the other hand, we're working on the anaerobic end of the spectrum
Because of the high resistance, there is compression of blood vessels within the working muscles. This leads to much higher blood pressures, up to 345/245 mmHg when squatting, along with higher levels of hormones like adrenaline to support force production.
Because of these reasons and more, the connection between your HR and the amount of oxgyen your cardiovascular system is pumping (VO2) is no longer the same
Research has shown VO2 can be as little as 50% of what would be seen during cadiovascular exercise at the same HR
That's why it's misleading to use HR alone during anaerobic exercises as a gauge for whether or not you're "doing cardio"
So while strength training does have many benefits and is important, that doesn't mean it's a substitute for good old-fashioned cardio
➡ Learn more at 8Weeksout - link in bio