Play It Again Sports - Fishers, IN

Play It Again Sports - Fishers, IN Improve your game with NEW or SLIGHTLY USED fitness and sports equipment from PLAY IT AGAIN SPORTS Fishers! We sell High-Quality USED sporting goods!

We sell NEW sporting goods and fitness equipment from major brand name manufacturers. We’ll buy your slightly USED GEAR from you. You can also trade in that USED GEAR for top quality, NEW or other slightly used athletic gear. Great prices on NEW and used treadmills, home gyms, weights, and the hottest new elliptical trainers and exercise bikes! Top-quality Proline golf equipment, lacrosse, hockey

, baseball, Adidas soccer, football, and more. Before you buy any new or used sports gear, visit PLAY IT AGAIN SPORTS FISHERS! We will meet or beat any competitor's (Online Too!) price on any current model item in stock.

Hoppy Easter from Play It Again Sports Carmel and Fishers! 🐰🐣We are closed today and will regain normal business hours t...
04/05/2026

Hoppy Easter from Play It Again Sports Carmel and Fishers! 🐰🐣
We are closed today and will regain normal business hours tomorrow!

03/06/2026

Play It Again Sports Fishers and Carmel stock a wide range of sports and fitness equipment used and new! We offer trade in credit and cash for your quality used gear every day with no appointments necessary! We accept competitor coupons!

From our shelves to your sleigh—load up on quality used & new gear for the athletes on your list and give the gift of pl...
12/06/2025

From our shelves to your sleigh—load up on quality used & new gear for the athletes on your list and give the gift of play. We have thousands of great gift ideas in stock!

We are thankful for your business! Play It Again Sports Carmel and Fishers would like to wish you and your whole team a...
11/27/2025

We are thankful for your business! Play It Again Sports Carmel and Fishers would like to wish you and your whole team a Happy Thanksgiving! We will be open 10-8 Friday with Black Friday specials!
#

11/25/2025

Ready to cash in on your quality used skates? Visit Play It Again Sports today!

11/21/2025

From your hands to someone else’s game—your gear still has life in it! Bring it to Play It Again Sports, get paid instantly, and keep the play going. 🏆 Presented by CCM.

To all those who have served and are still serving, we thank you!
11/11/2025

To all those who have served and are still serving, we thank you!

"No duty is more urgent than that of returning thanks." — James Allen 🙏 We are closed in honor of Memorial Day and will...
05/26/2025

"No duty is more urgent than that of returning thanks."
— James Allen 🙏
We are closed in honor of Memorial Day and will regain normal business hours tomorrow!

04/29/2025

Ready to upgrade your golf game? 🏌️‍♂️⛳️ Play It Again Sports is buying quality used golf gear – clubs, bags, balls, and more! We pay CASH every day for quality used golf equipment at our Carmel and Fishers locations! Swing by today!

04/18/2025

Baseball and Softball season is in full swing! Stop in to our Carmel, or Fishers locations for any gear you need during the season! We offer full glove re-stringing and break in services! We pay cash and offer trade credit for the quality used gear you no longer need! No appointments are necessary and we buy all sports year round!

Address

11681 Olio Road
Fishers, IN
46037

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 8pm
Tuesday 10am - 8pm
Wednesday 10am - 8pm
Thursday 10am - 8pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm
Sunday 11am - 4pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Play It Again Sports - Fishers, IN posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Play It Again Sports - Fishers, IN:

Shortcuts

Share

Category