Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN

Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN Locally owned franchise that has been buying and selling new and quality used inventory since 1992! Kids outgrow sports equipment so fast it’s amazing.

Trade in your used equipment to buy new at a discount, or buy used to save up to 50-70%! Recycle your quality used sports equipment at Play It Again Sports. Much of this gear is still in great condition and has lots of years left in it, which makes that cluttered garage or closet a potential source of income. Cashing in your quality used gear at your local Play It Again Sports is fast and easy:

C

lean out that closet, garage or basement! Load up your quality used brand name sports and fitness equipment and bring it to one of our stores. Check in with a sales associate to review what you have to sell or trade. While you check out the latest arrivals in the store, your sales associate will review your items based on condition, brand and the store's current stock levels. Your sales associate will determine the value of your items and either pay you on the spot or you can trade your items towards your purchase that day. You walk out of the store with new gear, money in your pocket or both!

06/15/2026

Happy Monday Michiana! We hope you’re enjoying this perfect weather and stayed safe last week 🙏🌞

For you golfers, we just got an EXCELLENT condition Cobra Tour Iron set 4-PW. All grips come equipped with Arcos installed! If you’re looking for a players iron and want to save on a full-retail set, we have them marked at $749.99.

Come check us out! We’re located just south of US 20 off exit 33. If you’ve never been, we’re always buying used sports equipment year round and are happy to assist with your sports equipment necessities!

💥 💥 New Product Alert!! 💥 💥 Nerf Disc Golf Discs now available! Drivers, Midranges and Putters.Various color choices. $...
06/12/2026

💥 💥 New Product Alert!! 💥 💥

Nerf Disc Golf Discs now available!
Drivers, Midranges and Putters.
Various color choices. $16.99

Don’t forget to bring those quality used trade-in items. We buy and trade everyday!

Foot bags are back in stock while supplies last!We weren’t able to get our full order, but we have a great selection tha...
06/09/2026

Foot bags are back in stock while supplies last!
We weren’t able to get our full order, but we have a great selection that won’t last long. Stop by today before it’s too late.

Boota Bags $7.99
Sandmasters $11.99

Now is the time to shop for those boat tubes, water skis and life jackets! We have both new and used inventory. And don’...
06/06/2026

Now is the time to shop for those boat tubes, water skis and life jackets! We have both new and used inventory. And don’t forget we buy and trade quality used sporting goods everyday!

Business will be Closed today so we can spend time with friends and family. We will be back open on Tuesday at 10:00am.
05/25/2026

Business will be Closed today so we can spend time with friends and family. We will be back open on Tuesday at 10:00am.

Happy May everyone! It’s been a loooong winter but now it’s finally GOLF season!Right now we have a BRAND NEW, still in ...
05/19/2026

Happy May everyone! It’s been a loooong winter but now it’s finally GOLF season!

Right now we have a BRAND NEW, still in plastic, Callaway Quantum (stiff/graphite) for $599!

And that’s the least of it! We’re loaded with left handed sets, affordable options for beginners (and your random work golf outing), tons of new and used individuals irons…even some vintage putters for you collectors!

Just enjoy the season! It’s gonna be an AWESOME summer Michiana, and we’d love seeing you .

Cheers!

05/14/2026

ELKHART VS MARIAN SOFTBALL

We still have Boota Bags and Sandmasters in stock! But they’re going quick and it might be awhile until we can get resto...
05/13/2026

We still have Boota Bags and Sandmasters in stock! But they’re going quick and it might be awhile until we can get restock. Jump on the trend and get yours today!

05/13/2026

Matt Yeakey and Keith Beber provide game commentary as the Elkhart Lions take on the Marian Knights in boys baseball, Wednesday, May 13th at 5:30. Michiana Video and WSBT-TVwill provide the game live streaming. Elkhart High School Athletics Elkhart Athletic Club - EAC

We have a gently used tabletop electronic scoreboard. Made by Sportable Scoreboards. New retail is $380. Our price is on...
05/11/2026

We have a gently used tabletop electronic scoreboard. Made by Sportable Scoreboards. New retail is $380. Our price is only $149!
We don’t get these very often and they sell quick. Check it out today!

Address

3527 S Main Street
Elkhart, IN
46517

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 8pm
Tuesday 10am - 8pm
Wednesday 10am - 8pm
Thursday 10am - 8pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm
Sunday 12pm - 5pm

Telephone

+15742932462

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN:

Shortcuts

Share

Category