Play It Again Sports - Carmel, IN

Play It Again Sports - Carmel, IN Play It Again Sports Carmel Sells New and Used Sports and Fitness Equipment. We guarantee the lowest price on all new products.

We service all fitness equipment and warranty the used products. Trade in and save, or sell for cash! We sell NEW sporting goods and fitness equipment from major brand name manufacturers. We sell High-Quality USED sporting goods! We’ll buy your slightly USED GEAR from you. You can also trade in that USED GEAR for top quality, NEW or other slightly used athletic gear. Great prices on NEW and used t

readmills, home gyms, weights, and the hottest new elliptical trainers and exercise bikes! Top-quality Proline golf equipment, lacrosse, hockey, baseball, Adidas soccer, football, and more. Before you buy any new or used sports gear, visit
Play It Again Sports Carmel --- your family headquarters for new and used sporting goods

06/18/2026

We’re looking to pay you CASH today! Bring in your quality used golf clubs and get paid on the spot, we offer either cash or store credit at both locations in Carmel and Fishers. Store credit works at both stores so you can find exactly what you’re wanting! Stop on any time, no appointment needed!

06/11/2026

We stock hundreds of new and used baseball bats, gloves, helmets, batting gloves, baseballs, accessories, and more! Stop in any time and trade in your equipment that you’re not using and save cash today! No appointment needed!

06/08/2026

Huge restock of over 15,000 pounds of hand weights, ankle weights, and other items. Stop in today and trade in your sporting goods that you’re not using to trade in and save cash today!

06/06/2026

we carry everything you need to have a great day out on the water, whether it’s kneeboarding, wake boarding, tubing, or water skiing. We offer both new and used options, including a 20% off sale on most new items in the store. Come on by as the temps are rising!

06/05/2026

We stock all things golf, new and used accessories, grips, shafts, technology, shoes, and whatever else you may need out on the course.

We pay cash and store credit for used golf items year round! Bring in your golf clubs, shoes, bags, and other items to ...
06/04/2026

We pay cash and store credit for used golf items year round! Bring in your golf clubs, shoes, bags, and other items to save while you shop our massive selection of used golf items for at both of our locations in Carmel and Fishers!

05/11/2026

Golf, Baseball-Softball, water sports, disc golf, bicycles and more are in stock at our Carmel and Fishers locations! We pay cash and offer trade-in credit every day for your quality used sports and fitness equipment with no appointments necessary! Turn your quality used gear into cash at Play It Again Sports, Carmel and Fishers!

04/28/2026

Golf season is here ! At play it again sports Carmel and fishers we pay premium cash and trade prices for premium golf clubs, bags, and many other golf related items! Stop by either the fishers or Carmel locations for more details on buying and selling golf clubs today!

04/19/2026

We pay cash and offer trade credit for quality used golf clubs and equipment every day with no appointments necessary! Our Carmel , and Fishers locations have thousands of quality used items in stock!

04/16/2026

Play It Again Sports Carmel and Fishers has a huge selection of quality-used sports and fitness equipment! We Pay Cash and offer Trade in Credit for your quality used sports and fitness items every day! We buy all sports all year round and no appointments are necessary! We specialize in golf, baseball, softball, fitness equipment, and any other sports item you can think of! Turn your used sports and fitness equipment into cash!

Address

2332 E 116th Street
Carmel, IN
46032

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 7pm
Tuesday 10am - 7pm
Wednesday 10am - 7pm
Thursday 10am - 7pm
Friday 10am - 7pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm
Sunday 12pm - 5pm

Telephone

+13178486044

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Play It Again Sports - Carmel, IN posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Play It Again Sports - Carmel, IN:

Shortcuts

Share

Category