08/27/2026
We will -Not- be carrying MTG or PokĆ©mon cards. Why? Because Iāve spent quite a bit of time researching the possibility, especially with the upcoming closure of Galactic Gaming and the vacuum that will leave downtown. I genuinely wanted to see if we could help fill that gap, but the more I looked at it, the more I realized that it simply isnāt viable with our current setup.
A true gaming store needs more than just shelves of cards. It needs space to build a communityāgaming tables, events, tournaments, tabletop nights, themed D&D rooms, devoted staff, and a place where people actually want to spend an afternoon.
And honestly, Iām shocked at the margins on MTG and PokĆ©mon. To be even somewhat competitive with online pricing, youāre often looking at roughly 10ā20% margins on some of the most sought-after products. D&D merchandise is a little better, but the model still requires significant volume and additional revenue streams to make the numbers work.
Thatās a labor of passion and love, and I have enormous respect for the people who make it work.
The problem is that doing it right would mean an entirely different setup for usāprobably an entire building dedicated to gaming. There are several buildings downtown that could be incredible for something like this: large gaming rooms, tabletop spaces, card tournaments, themed D&D rooms, youth events, and a real community hub.
But that kind of project would require an investment of several hundred thousand dollars, and that simply isnāt a risk I can take right now.
I also know myself well enough to admit that I have a tendency to spread myself too thin. š Our current nicheābooks, manga, snacks, gifts, and the weird little things that make The Blessed Fig Tree what it isāis solid. I donāt want to jeopardize that by trying to become something we arenāt equipped to be.
That said, the vacuum is real. Seeing Galactic Gaming close is genuinely depressing for downtown. I grew up in gaming stores, and they have a special place in my heart. Theyāre not just retail storesāthey can be incredibly important social outlets, especially for young people.
If someone has the funding, building, or ability to put together a very favorable loan arrangementāparticularly someone who sees it as an investment in the future of downtownāI honestly think there is an opportunity here.
There are buildings downtown that could be absolutely fantastic for this.
Iāve been kicking this idea around for a while, and I wanted to finally put it out there. Iām just not convinced itās a wise risk for my current setup.
So, for now: no MTG or PokƩmon at the Fig Tree.
But if gaming is your dream, Antigo has a pretty interesting hole waiting to be filled.
Cheers. š»