24/03/2026
The Munster Junior Cup first round match against Newcastle West took place at the home venue on Saturday evening 21/03/2026 under lights. It was probably always destined to be a close encounter given both sides ended up pretty close on the MJ league table – so the scene was set for the battle. Skibbereen fielded a strong team but minus a few strong players - but such is sport and you play with what you have. Over the years we have had a few strong runs in this prestigious Cup and given our powerful performances to date against the best in the J1 league, there was an expectation we might just get a good run this time round. Not to be I’m afraid – though close at the finish, the visitors literally kicked themselves to victory in the final minute of the game when the sides were level at 15 – 15. And a difficult kick it was too- on or about the 22 and about a metre or two from the touchline. A miss would have resulted in extra time having to be played, but Lady Luck was with the visitors, the kick was successful – game over 18 -15 – and the end of MJCup outing this season for Skibb. Such kicks when successful bring great joy to one team – and downright heartbreak to the other – the highs and lows of sport.
To say it was an exciting game would be a bit of an exaggeration – but it did have its moments – and given the rub of the green Skibb probably should have sailed home with points to spare- but the wheels did come off from time to time, calls went against us, and a few unintended errors at critical moments denied us points and victory.
Newcastle West got off to the better start and attacked out wide with some powerful running from their backs – choreographed by their very efficient outhalf – and together they gave the home defence a hard time for the opening 15 minutes. Persistent pounding at the opportunity door by NCW finally did yield results with a try and conversion to give the visitors a 7-0 lead. Not to be outdone Skibbereen mounted their offensive from the restart and when No.8 Conan O’Farrell took possession in midfield and bolted, he had a lot of work to do, but power, strength and determination saw him ward off defenders to score a great individual try under the posts – and nearly knocking over this poor scribe – apologies for the poor photo Conan– and not the first time. Dave Shannon added the points and the sides were level again.
Suddenly Skibb started to come alive and in the leadup to halftime played some of their best rugby and were it not for a deliberate knock-on by NCW I’m sure we were in for another try. That said the resultant penalty kick to the corner by Shannon didn’t seem to compensate one bit – or even the yellow card to the offender. At the time Skibb winger Matthew Benn had a clear path to the tryline, when the intended pass was interrupted – the referee called a penalty - a little closer and a penalty try would/should have been awarded – no question. The resultant 5 metre lineout saw Skibbereen drive for the line – and then the melee started – and took a few minutes to sort – not I might add to the satisfaction of the home side – and a penalty awarded to NCW. However, as luck would have it Skibb did win a penalty from the ensuing ruck and Dave Shannon kicked Skibb ahead by three points to leave the halftime score 10-7 to Skibb.
Into the second half, it took Skibb a while to get into their stride but they were demonstrating their offensive strength in quick breaks and smart off-loading. In one such move Skibb centre Rawiri Wereta collected a pass and wound his way through defenders with the goal line at his mercy. Support was close at hand in Dave Shannon and when Rawiri went to ground 2 metres from home, the offload was foremost in his mind and Shannon duly collected and drove on to ‘score’ – sadly no – the referee cited a forward pass – try disallowed – scrum to NCW – the pain of it.
Shortly after the end result was to be more positive for a change, when Ciaran Coombes was the centre of attention when he collected a fine pass from Tom Beare as he careered down the touchline with defenders close behind. Ciaran knew it was a do or die situation and he opted to go it alone and strive for home – which he did with distinction and touched down almost on the corner flag – for another fine individual try. And so, controversy never too far away as always, Dave Shannon lined up the difficult conversion and it seemed to sail between the posts – and the umpires raised their flags – well one did anyway – but NCW defenders said it went under rather than over the crossbar – back to the ref – conversion disallowed. Skibb were now 15 – 7 ahead and looking good.
Obviously NCW could see the momentum changing and realised the game was getting away from them and mounted a series of attacks that ultimately yielded a penalty, which brought the score to 15 -10, but were now once again within striking distance of Skibbereen. So, put it down to a better NCW ‘bench’ or a slackening off by the home side, or the belief they might weather the storm and hold the lead to the finish. It didn’t work out like that – NCW were the better team in the final quarter and they kept the pressure firmly and surely on the home side. All the activity during that time saw Skibb defending as NCW attacked through the centre channel – and then out wide on both flanks. They had the momentum and the belief and gave it just about everything – the try coming eventually – but no conversion – so the sides tied at 15 -15 into the final stages – until their penalty kick sealed victory.
Without a doubt we were unlucky on the night and if one considers the disallowed try and the ‘suspect’ conversion it seems okay to feel aggrieved. That said I question also the advantage ruling where it pertains to those ‘infamous’ knock-ons. Not the deliberate knock-on as such – that is a different issue, but there is debate on that too. No. I refer to the old common knock-on which we are all familiar with – ball spilt forward, fumbled catch etc. Ultimately advantage is at the discretion of the referee – but provision is there to allow the non-offending team get some advantage – instead of the ref just stopping the game and awarding the usual scrum to the non-offending team. I witnessed two situations at least where NCW knocked-on and Skibb continued play by instinctively booting the ball forward towards the NCW tryline – a clear advantage – but not allowed - and the ref calls play back for a scrum. Getting the put-in for a scrum falls a long way short of the distinct advantage that could have accrued if the forward in question had been allowed continue. A subject for debate - or better still an updating on the rule for referees. See below:-
Waving an arm forward and calling "advantage
Referees should apply the advantage rule in rugby when a knock-on infringement occurs, allowing play to continue until the non-offending team gains territory or a try-scoring chance. The referee signals advantage by waving an arm forward and calling "advantage!" and may keep an arm raised to show the players and supporters that the team is still playing under the advantage rule. If the non-offending team gains enough territory or a chance to score, the referee will call "advantage over," which means the original infringement has been cancelled, and play will restart as normal.
A big Congrats to the Boys U16 – a great win in Cork – well done lads.
1Kieran Shannon, 2Donnchadh Maguire, 3James Williams, 4Adam Sheehan, 5Kevin Coombes, 6Jack Kent, 7Christopher Benn, 8Conan Farrell, 9Oisín Dinan, 10Will Canavan, 11Ciarán Coombes, 12Rawiri Wereta, 13Thomas Beare, 14Matthew Benn, 15David Shannon, 16Cathal Mccarthy, 17Lorcan Carey, 18Tomek Lechtanski, 19Eric O'Brien, 20scott fuller, 21Callum Hurley, 22Matthew Sheehan