13/06/2026
John Connolly, the Barrhead-born outside-left, and as a Toffees fan you'll know his Goodison story is pure 1970s Everton drama.
The basics
• Born: 13 June 1950, Barrhead, Scotland
• Position: outside left / left winger
• Clubs: St Johnstone (1968-1972), Everton (1972-1976), Birmingham City (1976-1978), Newcastle United, Hibernian, Gateshead, Blyth Spartans — 344 league apps, 84 goals in total
Everton years (1972-1976)
Harry Catterick really did haul himself out of a sick bed to get the deal done in March 1972 — £75,000 to St Johnstone was big money then, and Catterick's determination became part of the legend.
At Goodison he made 108 league appearances and scored 16 goals.
While he was a Blue:
• he won his only full Scotland cap, away to Switzerland in Bern on 22 June 1973 (a 1-0 friendly defeat), having already picked up four Under-23 caps
• he suffered two separate leg breaks — both serious setbacks that disrupted his pace-based game
• when Catterick left and Billy Bingham took over, the relationship never clicked. Connolly eventually asked out
The move away, September 1976, Birmingham City paid £90,000 to take him to St Andrew's. He spent two seasons there (57 league games, 9 goals), then went on to Newcastle and Hibs — famously lining up alongside George Best at Easter Road.
Later he became a successful manager, leading Queen of the South to the Scottish Second Division title in 2001-02 and the Challenge Cup the next year, before a brief return to St Johnstone.
It's a classic tale of what might have been at Everton — Catterick saw him as the natural width on the left, but injuries and a managerial change meant Goodison never saw the best of that Barrhead winger for long.
fans