03/19/2020
After the Thistles' Cup win in January, 1907 there was still a matter to attend to-- winning the Manitoba Hockey League championship. The Thistles, now the hunted, and no longer truly "amateur", brought in future HOFers Fred Whitcroft (goal scorer extraordinaire for the OHA Peterborough Colts), Alf Smith and Harry "Rat" Westwick (both veterans of the fabulous Ottawa "Silver Seven" of the ECAHA) to offset the losses of Art Ross and Joe Hall, who had both returned back to Brandon, and of the injured Si Griffis, who had a lingering and problematic ankle injury.
By the end of the season, the Thistles found themselves tied in the standings with the upstart Brandon club and on March 16th began a best-of-3 playoff in Winnipeg to decide the winner of the league-- with the Stanley Cup at stake! Though the games were hard fought, Brandon, who lost team spark-plug Joe Hall to a broken thumb halfway through the second game, could not overcome the Thistles' significant offensive firepower, and fell to the champs in two games, by the scores of 8-6 and 4-1, respectively.
Now it was the Thistles' turn to accept the ECAHA champ Montreal Wanderers' challenge for the Cup, but this time, the series wouldn't be played in the east-- the series would be played in Kenora-- in two days! Fate, long being on the Thistles' side, would quickly deal the club two big blows. With the early spring Kenora ice surface being deemed unsatisfactory to skate upon, the series was moved up to Winnipeg and delayed by two days. The other blow was that, after a formal protest filed by the Montreal team against Alf Smith and Harry Westwick (basically the 1907 version of modern day 'rent-a-players'), the two were ruled by Stanley Cup trustee Bill Foran as being ineligible to play!
By March 23rd, the series was on-- but the Thistles had managed to convince the Wanderers to let Westwick and Smith play, much to Foran's displeasure. So incensed was he over being pushed out of the final decision, he threatened to take the the famed chalice back east and declare the championship void!
(To better read this the newspaper article below make sure to click on the photo, select Options and select "Download")