08/12/2014
Ok, so I am searching the internet, searching for more knowledge on how to improve my squat and I come across something that says; “Barbell Squat: the Worst Exercise in Existence”….
I had to read…
I will give the link to people if you message me, but I will not support an idiot such as this to the public.
There are multiple points that he brings up and I am going to give my rebuttal to them. Not to defend the squat to this hack. Simply to make sure that if there are more of these ignorant individuals out there, which there are, you have scientific knowledge to back up your confidence in addressing them for the ignorant person they are.
The first…
- “Loading the top of the spine — which in many respects is a pyramid — with a 200, 250, 300, 350, 400+ … pound bar, and then moving that bar up and down a few feet, does not seem especially wise in and of itself.”
So! The people that are loading the 45 pound bar with this much weight are experienced lifters and are not usually loading the weight at the top of the spine, which is where you cervical spine is. That amount of weight on your c-spine could potentially break your neck. So he’s correct in this statement. Where he is not correct is in assuming that loading the spine with weight is bad. The spine is our support system, and we are not meant to walk around like slobs. We are meant to walk up right, with our head in a neutral position, and our feet straight ahead. Not slumped over, with our head down, walking like a duck. When we force our bodies to perform these basic functions under load, we are strengthening the core muscles that allow us to perform these functions efficiently.
Second…
- “The primary muscles that most squatters intend to work, are the muscles of the legs, which are huge muscles, surrounding huge bones, supported and surrounded by comparatively huge joints.”
The people that are performing a squat are intending to hit legs, back, abdominal muscles, hip flexors, and a few other muscles. The muscles of the leg are moderately large and are not the biggest muscles in the body by any means. The largest muscle in the body is the latisimus dorsi. This is a back muscle on each side of your body. This muscle helps to support your spine. Squats make this muscle work. In order to make a muscle work, you must put it under tension and time. With the lats, and other back muscles, working to stabilize your spine; they become stronger under weight.
Third…
- The barbell squat is absolutely self-defeating. Why? Because success in a barbell squat means primarily, stronger legs. Stronger and stronger legs will need more and more resistance.”…. “The stronger you get, and the more success you have performing a barbell squat, the more ineffective and dangerous the exercise becomes. The risk of injury not only increases, but so does the actual effect of a potential injury.”
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!
Now that I have gotten that out of my system.
Stronger and stronger legs will definitely need more resistance in order to continue growth. Truth.
“The more success you have at performing a barbell squat, the more ineffective and dangerous the exercise becomes”
WHAT?! So basically what this du***ss is saying is that when you are doing this correctly you are hurting yourself. WRONG. When you do this incorrectly, you are hurting yourself. The squat is a whole body movement. It requires strength in all areas to become successful in it. Period. If you are not strong in one area of it, you will see it immediately and you will be made aware of it by your coach or trainer.
As for the last part of this quote…Potential injury? The only injury that matters is the one that you are experiencing, because you did something wrong. If you do the squat correctly, you will not be injured, you will actually be taking a proactive role in preventing injuries in other parts of your body….SUCH AS YOUR BACK.
PLEASE. Do not allow people like this to tell you that the barbell squat is a bad movement. These people are ignorant to the benefits of the movement. When you are able to perform better in everyday life because of this movement, you will thank me. Do NOT listen to this hack or anyone of his kind.
What a du***ss…