09/04/2026
ORCHARD PARK — Greg Dortch played baseball growing up. But that's not how he learned to track punts.
His father would throw the ball high in the air for a young Dortch to catch. Over and over. Pretty simple, right?Well, that's not the biggest reason Dortch became a quality NFL punt returner. No, he believes the reason is confidence and fearlessness. And that's something that wasn't sold separately.
It takes guts to field punts, knowing eyes have to somehow track the ball falling from the sky while being aware of opposing players sprinting downfield looking for a big hit. According to Pro Football Focus, the average NFL hangtime is 4.5 seconds, which means a punt returner has to track the ball, decide whether to catch it and whether to return it in that window.
"Looking up at the sky while the other guys are running full speed at you — just the guts that it takes, that confidence that it takes to do that job," Dortch told GNN Sports after practice Wednesday. "It's not for everybody."
Dortch, who was born in Rochester and moved to Virginia as a child, knows almost as soon as he catches a punt whether he's going to have a crease. It takes peripheral vision to be a punt returner and Dortch says he usually has time or "two peeks" before taking his first step after catching the ball"It's really freaky," Dortch said. "I have like a photographic memory and know where everybody is. It's really freaky. It's a gift. It's not something everybody has."
The Bills signed Dortch to the practice squad Monday in hopes he could be a solution to their punt return holes.
Buffalo has struggled to find an adequate punt returner since losing faith in the decision-making of former all-rookie return specialist Brandon Codrington early last season. The Bills signed Mecole Hardman Jr. midseason, but a pulled hamstring on his first attempt ended that plan.
Khalil Shakir led the team with 16 returns, but his main job was to make smart decisionsThe Bills forced 68 punts last season and only returned 30 of them, Shakir being responsible for nine of the team's 14 fair catches. Buffalo ranked 30th in the NFL at 6.5 yards per return, with Shakir's 7.8 yards per return ranking well below the league's 10.2 average.
So the Bills have tried Dee Alford, Keon Coleman, Ray Davis and Hardman with seriousness during the preseason. It seemed to be Davis' job to lose, but he may have lost it after a m**fed punt against the Pittsburgh Steelers in the preseason finale.
With Hardman's release, the job will likely fall to Alford, Dortch or Shakir, the latter of whom is dealing with an injury and head coach Joe Brady has stated he prefers not to use there. But the question remains, how necessary is a dynamic returner?
The easy statistic to reference in support of a strong returner is field position. The Bills ranked 26th in the league, with average drive starts at their own 29.7-yard line.In 2024, the Bills led the league in average drive start, while Codrington ranked fourth with 11.4 yards per punt return. But a closer look makes the argument murky.
The difference in leading the league in drive starts and ranking 26th? Fewer than four yards. The Bills gave up fewer yards per drive last season than in 2024, but they forced 12 fewer turnovers. Buffalo also forced 11 turnovers in opponents' territory in 2024, compared to seven a year ago.
Still, punt returns are an important part of field position. The Bills offense averaged more yards per drive, punted fewer times and had a better net average when they did, gave up fewer points and had a better kick return average than in 2024, but still had worse field position.
And if Dortch is eventually Buffalo's long-term answer — he must be signed to the active roster to play more than three games — don't bank on many fair catches.Since Dortch became Arizona's primary punt returner in 2022, Dortch's 92 returns rank second in the NFL and he averaged 9.1 yards per return. But of the players in the top 10, Dortch has 10 fewer fair catches (21) than anyone else and only has one career m**f.
"If I catch the ball, I'm going to force you to tackle me," Dortch said. "I don't want you to have to let up or just think that I'm going to Faitlr catch it. If I can get 15 yards for Josh (Allen) to set us up, that's huge. Anytime I can steal yards, I try to."