The Sweeter Side

The Sweeter Side Your destination for all things custom! From luxury cookies and cakes to hand-painted banners and 3D printed decor, we handle the details so you can celebrate.

Founded by Erika, run by Erika & Leah: neighbors by chance, partners by choice. 🥂 The Sweeter Side was founded in 2022 by Erika Gerpe and soon after joined by neighbor-turned-partner, Leah Vitez. What started as a one-woman bakery quickly became a creative dream team. Together, we whip up custom cookies, cakes, hand-painted banners, and one-of-a-kind party decor — all made with a little artistry and a lot of heart.

The last day of school countdown is on.. and our teachers deserve something sweet after surviving an entire school year!...
06/04/2026

The last day of school countdown is on.. and our teachers deserve something sweet after surviving an entire school year!

Our teacher gift packs are open for pre-order and we will only have a limited quantity so please get your orders in ASAP before they run out!

This 3 pack will be $15, and as always custom orders are always available!

Please text us as 845-618-5319 to secure your order!

Not one but TWO new lawyers in the building! Double the graduation sets means double the celebration for our favorite ne...
06/03/2026

Not one but TWO new lawyers in the building! Double the graduation sets means double the celebration for our favorite new and grads! Objection to anyone who says you can have too many cookies. 🏛️🍪

A new little witch or wizard is on the way! ✨👶 We loved bringing this magical Harry Potter theme to life… And yes, the S...
06/03/2026

A new little witch or wizard is on the way! ✨👶 We loved bringing this magical Harry Potter theme to life… And yes, the Sorting Hat cupcakes will decide if baby is a Gryffindor or a Slytherin! 🪄🧁 Which house are you placing your bets on? 👇
MagicalMoments CustomBaking

Standard issue sweet treats for the newest EMT on the block! 🚑🍪 Huge congratulations to John on his accomplishment!✨Cust...
06/03/2026

Standard issue sweet treats for the newest EMT on the block! 🚑🍪 Huge congratulations to John on his accomplishment!✨

Custom cookies are the PERFECT personalized gift for any milestone! Visit the link in bio to start your order today 😋

05/20/2026

Honk if you’re turning one! 🪿✨ We can’t lie we were obsessed with this “One Silly Goose” theme set. The full celebration package included a gorgeous 2-tier display cake, matching custom cookies, and the most perfect little smash cake for the guest of honor!

DM us to book a custom treats package for your little one’s big milestone 😋






•
•
•
•
✨ First Birthday Custom Cakes & Cookies ✨
One Silly Goose birthday theme • first birthday cake ideas • custom smash cake near me • Hudson Valley bakery • Orange County NY custom cakes • Chester NY • bespoke sugar cookies • 2 tier birthday cake • luxury kids party treats • trendy first birthday ideas

Kitty-cat-astrophe averted! 🐱💖 We handcrafted a total SuperKitties universe for our Breezy F baby. We did the full Sweet...
05/20/2026

Kitty-cat-astrophe averted! 🐱💖 We handcrafted a total SuperKitties universe for our Breezy F baby.
We did the full Sweeter Side spread: custom cake, matching cookies, a hand painted banner, and our NEW custom balloon arches! So excited to officially add balloon decor to our party packages. 🎈✨

Send us a message now to check availability for your next event!






•
•
•
•
✨ Custom Party Decor & Bakery Orders ✨
Custom cakes near me • Hudson Valley bakery • Orange County NY custom cakes • Chester NY party decor • SuperKitties birthday party ideas • custom balloon arches NY • handmade party banners • luxury kids birthday themes • bespoke sugar cookies • event styling Orange County NY • birthday party packages

Donut mind if we do…🍩🩵 A little custom donut drip cake inspo to brighten up your feed today 😋DM us to check availability...
05/20/2026

Donut mind if we do…🍩🩵 A little custom donut drip cake inspo to brighten up your feed today 😋
DM us to check availability for your next event! ✨

•
•
•
•
✨ Custom Cake Inspiration & Orders ✨
Custom cakes near me • Hudson Valley bakery • Orange County NY custom cakes • cakes • bespoke birthday cake ideas • drip cake design • luxury party desserts • local baker • custom treats NY • celebration cakes

A beautiful day for a beautiful boy. 🫶🏼 We were so honored to create this custom cookie set for Karter’s baptism. So muc...
05/13/2026

A beautiful day for a beautiful boy. 🫶🏼 We were so honored to create this custom cookie set for Karter’s baptism. So much love to ! 🕊️✨

Address

Chester, NY
10918

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Sweeter Side posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share