25/03/2026
For several years, we have observed how inconsistent refereeing can negatively influence the quality of competitions, particularly when they involve young children.
To clarify, this statement is not intended to criticize any individual referee or umpire, but rather to highlight that, in many cases, current competition structures are not appropriately adapted for children.
In pattern-based disciplines (such as tull or kata), determining a winner is often challenging. In many instances, decisions appear to be based more on identifying who performed “less poorly” rather than who demonstrated clear excellence. At this developmental stage, many children have not yet refined their techniques sufficiently to allow for objective and consistent evaluation. As a result, referees are often left with significant subjective discretion, which can lead to decisions influenced more by personal perception than by measurable quality.
At the same time, competition organizers frequently face difficulties in securing highly qualified referees. This challenge arises from multiple factors, including financial constraints and limited regional availability of experienced officials. Consequently, it is not uncommon to see junior competitors—or, in some cases, even parents—serving as referees. Under such circumstances, maintaining a high standard of officiating becomes understandably difficult.
These issues often lead to frustration among children, coaches, and parents alike. Explaining competition outcomes to young participants—particularly why they lost or why another competitor was deemed better—can be especially challenging when the criteria are unclear or subjective.
For these reasons, we at Children’s Games strongly believe that martial arts competitions for children should be designed differently—making them more appropriate, transparent, and understandable for participants, coaches, and parents. Tasks and evaluation criteria should be clear, objective, and measurable, with results that are easy to interpret.
The Children’s Games “Let’s Play Martial Arts” initiative is a competition concept specifically designed to create an enjoyable, relaxed, and engaging experience for children, as well as for coaches and parents. By encouraging children to demonstrate their skills in a playful yet structured environment, this approach maintains the competitive element while fostering motivation, enjoyment, and long-term interest—without generating unnecessary frustration.